Possible Clues:

• Shiner
• One of the Shinners is missing the North? That'll come as a blow!
• Stigma
• Be without servant, having facial bruising
• Visual face painting? You didn¿t see that coming
• Ring souvenir?
• With the top cut off one has lost one seer, perhaps
• One of those things the boxer might give comes as a blow
• Facial mark: poodle has to live without it
• Evidence of fight to be hidden by servant? On the contrary