Related Clues:

• Like "The X-Files"
• Too coincidental
• Like a Stephen King story
• Shiver-causing
• Alien
• Reminiscent of Poe
• Creeping you out
• Likely to creep one out
• Blood-curdling
• Supernatural
• Able to creep you out
• Inducing fear
• Really strange
• Like many an M. Night Shyamalan film
• Goosebump-causing