Possible Clues:

• Unusual, unnatural craving for food in Italy leaving one puzzled
• It's not the usual answer? It's what you'd expect and it's frustrating!
• In misdirected play, I act out of character
• Surprising to see
• Unusual to have year in exotic capital
• Out of character in play, I act badly
• Play I act badly out of character
• Unusual year in transformed capital
• Year in capital strangely unrepresentative
• American representative not characteristic