Possible Clues:

• Puts in an unsuitable role
• Young woman threw in unsuitable candidates for role
• Gives player the wrong job to address tackling all the players
• Chooses the wrong actor
• Gives non-fishing actor angling role -- with these results?
• Assigns an actor to an unsuitable role
• Decides Lassie is acting the maggot as Chuck, Arnie and Sly have their heads in the clouds?
• Picks the wrong actors
• Puts in the wrong part
• Picks the wrong actor