Possible Clues:

• Punch-up
• Possibly a bareknuckle encounter
• Dukes will be involved in this duel?
• Female at first rubbished this gift, causing a punch-up
• Female is drunk, engaging another female in tussle
• Dispute involving four dukes?
• Combat between people with no arms, paradoxically
• Ray, perhaps, not entirely mean to eat morsel of food, a scrap
• This fine gift may be exchanged for scrap
• Hand-to-hand battle