Possible Clues:

• One's not in a mainstream religion
• Infidel quietly once more abandoning island
• Heathen taking cooking vessel across Georgia
• Polytheist, to early Christians
• Opening up an atheist
• One not accepting your god
• Rose leaves parsonage with ungodly type
• Heathen; non-believer
• Father to irritate in return -- he won't be celebrating Christmas
• Face packs are good for a heathen