Related Clues:

• 'You have gotta be kidding me!'
• "___ I care!"
• A filter's incomplete? That won't happen!
• A filter shortened? That's ridiculous
• Expression of incredulity disgraced cricketer
• Assuming
• A riddle almost producing expression of disbelief
• A riddle with no conclusion? You're joking!
• Some fellas I fancy? I very much doubt it!
• Disgraced cricketer's incredulous expression
• Indignant "Clueless" quote
• "Seriously?!"
• I don't believe that a riddle should be shortened
• With 36-Down, literally, beyond rational explanation
• "Don't be a spoilsport!"