Related Clues:
- Like "Tales from the Darkside"
- Causing heebie-jeebies
- Strangely frightening
- Gooseflesh-making
- Like many a Poe tale
- Mighty strange
- Like old graveyards at midnight
- Way weird
- Weirdly strange
- Not just odd
- Like some extreme coincidences
- Shiver-producing
- Like a coincidence that makes you go 'Hmm ...'
- Ecstasy lake is frightening
- Not at all ordinary