Related Clues:
- Causing the heebie-jeebies
- More than strange
- Sickening
- An ___ resemblance
- Like Stephen King stories
- Frighteningly strange
- Spookily weird
- Supernaturally strange
- Like freakish coincidences
- Too weird for words
- Like Serling stories
- Unexplainable, maybe
- Like Rod Serling tales
- Causing shivers, perhaps
- Fear-inducing