Related Clues:

• Far from the usual
• Like Rod Serling's stories
• "How peculiar"
• Sort of scary
• ___ man out
• Like a poltergeist
• More than unsettling
• Inspiring jitters
• Like 7 or 17
• Oddly familiar
• Like 'Paranormal Activity'
• Like "Paranormal Activity"
• Spooky, weird
• Spooky, unearthly
• Peculiar, being uneven