Related Clues:

• Nearing depletion
• Like lots of items posted on Craigslist
• Went wild for
• Not worth as much, probably
• Like thrift shop merchandise
• Party leftover
• Enjoyed to the max
• Like thrift shop buys
• Cheaper, usually
• Needing a refill
• New's opposite
• Played for a cat's-paw
• Completely pooped
• Common recyclable
• Like cars in many classifieds