Related Clues:

• Hauntingly strange
• Inspiring shivers
• Halloweenlike
• Like "Tales from the Darkside"
• Causing heebie-jeebies
• Strangely frightening
• Gooseflesh-making
• Like many a Poe tale
• Mighty strange
• Like old graveyards at midnight
• Way weird
• Weirdly strange
• Not just odd
• Like some extreme coincidences
• Shiver-producing