Related Clues:

• Too weird or coincidental
• Like a coincidence that raises the hair on the back of your neck
• Like the sound of a theremin
• Like Poe's moods
• Disturbingly weird
• Halloweenish
• Like many Poe stories
• Like King novels
• Causing the heebie-jeebies
• Not exactly middle-of-the-road
• More than strange
• An ___ resemblance
• Like Stephen King stories
• Frighteningly strange
• Spookily weird