Possible Clues:

• Dodgy faction holds unique selling point
• Believe America's power is in clutches of fanatical group
• Consider to be likely
• Think American pressure is splitting religious group
• Colonel Mustard, for one
• American priest in religious group, one wanted by the police?
• Who may be caught in crooked set-ups?
• Believe to be guilty without proof
• One thought guilty
• Fancy cups set out