Possible Clues:

• Buddy Holly "My Two Timin' ___"
• She took gold, keeping mum
• "Witchy __": Eagles hit
• Helen Reddy's "I Am __"
• Lennon hit on "Double Fantasy"
• Glenn Close or Sean Young
• John Lennon's last million-selling single
• Word in a Helen Reddy title
• Eve, e.g.
• Randolph-Macon student