Possible Clues:

• Theatrical
• Good person, mature, with yen that's exaggerated
• Rising poet is full of gravity but a bit theatrical
• Overdramatic, bringing the old guns back!
• Camp for men only curtailed vision
• Much too theatrical: buck up you old ...
• Deer you once knocked over — very dramatic
• Upset, say, get theatrical
• Contrived (var.)
• Exaggerated or artificial, in the manner of actors