Possible Clues:

• Lose the right to fish in well
• Effort I made to pay penalty
• Surrender, as a penalty
• In trouble, receiving extremely feeble penalty
• It has to be paid or given up as a penalty
• Lose fish dropped in well
• Fresh offer - it is fine
• Lose right to
• Something given up as penalty
• What you have to pay to be a quadruped, by the sound of it