Possible Clues:

• Young toad initially found in pond!
• Pond dweller
• Eye of ___ (witches' brew need)
• Speaker before Dennis
• "Contract With America" first name
• Has to get on to be a scientist in water
• Pond creature
• Salamandridae family member
• Beside fresh tea in the water
• Eye of ___ (part of a "Macbeth" recipe)