Possible Clues:

• Honor for playing well with others?
• Best Choreography, for one
• Award for "Hadestown"
• Play securing new award
• Award for "Sweeney Todd"
• Unknown figure in no way up for an award
• Best Play award, say
• Soprano's award for performing?
• Playwright Kushner
• Any of the annual awards bestowed by the American Theatre Wing (New York)