Possible Clues:

• Play safe with hammer
• First head of church to find God with flock never wants to grow up
• Play safe, trimming piece of glass
• Fly guy?
• Barrie's hero
• JM Barrie's boy who never grows up?
• Fancy notepaper, nonetheless, for arrested juvenile
• Brand of peanut butter named for a literary character
• Boy who never grew up
• Boyish creation of J.M. Barrie