Possible Clues:

• Byrds number one hit in 1965
• Song by Bob Dylan, released on his 1965 album 'Bringing It All Back Home'
• Version of marimba tune norm in popular song
• Title guy asked to "play a song for me," in a Byrds hit
• Atlantic -------- (Rod Stewart album)
• Bob Dylan hit
• Bob Dylan-penned hit of 1965