Possible Clues:

• "___ Burr, Sir" ("Hamilton" song)
• Slugger Judge
• Judge in New York
• Baseball record-setter of 4/8/74
• Early priest
• First in ''Who's Who in the Bible''
• Duelist Burr
• "Fanfare for the Common Man" composer Copland
• Slugger of note
• 4/8/74 record breaker