Possible Clues:

• John Cougar "Nothin' Matters and What If ___"
• Plain White T's "Didn't mean for this to go as far as ___"
• Tanya Tucker "Oh What ___ to Me"
• Sheryl Crow "It don't hurt like ___"
• Brad Paisley song
• Mellencamp "Nothing Matters and What if ___"
• Brad Paisley "5th Gear" song