Possible Clues:

• Religious outcast
• Doctrine rejecter
• Religious nonconformist
• Non-believer
• Unorthodox believer at this place twitching
• Dissident now gets credit cut
• That woman returned call for person not acting in good faith?
• At this point the jerk may have got a burn
• The woman to call up, a person with the wrong outlook
• One seriously straying from the flock?