Possible Clues:

• This magician working with fakir might make fruit cocktails
• Officer from church gets university award for playing the devil's advocate perhaps
• Believer in the supernatural
• Superior officer and copper incline to apprehend tenor, one behaving mysteriously
• One who believes in the supernatural
• Witch, e.g
• Like Denis Wheatley - a dabbler in magic without realism
• Ornate stucco tile cut for black artist
• Supernatural believer