Possible Clues:

• Roger the reviewer
• Man with a respected thumb
• "Questions for the Movie Answer Man" author
• Roger who co-hosted 'Sneak Previews'
• Roger with an influential thumb
• Critic who said "Art is the closest we can come to understanding how a stranger really feels"
• Host of the annual Overlooked Film Festival
• Pulitzer-winning reviewer
• Movie maker ... or breaker?
• Chicago-based critic