Possible Clues:

• Holding underwater device with all toes, maybe, look up
• Figure butcher's returned fisherman's device
• Receptacle for holding catch of fish
• Number look around fish store
• A number secretly look up to find one holding catch
• Number to look up? There's a catch in it
• Having played successfully, there'll be a catch in it
• Number having sly look over angler's accessory
• Being suspended from the bank, there's likely a catch in it
• I hold catch, as goalies do