Possible Clues:

• Unsaintly soul
• Baddie always taking in the old, I gather
• Describes the man downstairs at party expressing hesitation to the wrong guy presumably?
• I have returned and converted older sinner
• Always protecting one old-fashioned sinner
• Bad actor - it's criminal!
• One committing wicked deeds
• Is older, I've found out, and a bad type
• One making lover die?
• Worry over idle miscreant